ZIP code profile · 2024 county data

ZIP Code 54891

Bayfield County, Wisconsin: Census demographics for this ZIP plus the containing county's FBI UCR crime rate.

Data updated 2026-08-24

499
Property rate /100K (county)
3,338
Population (ZIP)
62
Violent rate /100K (county)

Is ZIP code 54891 safe? Honest data snapshot

ZIP code 54891 sits within Bayfield County, WI. The figures below are the county's own FBI UCR numbers for 2024, the most accurate available statistic for this location, not a ZIP-specific calculation.

Bayfield County reported a violent-crime rate of 62 per 100,000 residents and a property-crime rate of 499 per 100,000 in 2024, drawing on county-level agency submissions.

Based on just 10 reported violent incidents across a county population of 16,220, this count is too low to support a reliable per-100K rate comparison. It may reflect a genuinely low-crime county, or it may reflect incomplete agency-level reporting to the FBI UCR Program for this county and year, small county-level counts are common in FBI Table 10 and should be treated as a data point, not a precise safety ranking.

ZIP 54891 is the largest ZIP in Bayfield County by population, 3,338 residents (#1 of 10 county ZIPs), across 68.52 square miles (49/sq mi). For a full breakdown of Bayfield County's crime categories and year-over-year trend, see the Bayfield County crime page linked below.

ZIP 54891 has no FBI-native crime rate (postal codes are not police jurisdictions). The property-led county proxy above is from Bayfield County agency submissions; see methodology for the ZCTA plurality map. Methodology.

ZIP 54891 Census context

These are ZIP/ZCTA demographic estimates, separate from the county-level FBI proxy above. They describe the local settlement, not a crime rate.

Median household income
$62,443
Median age
49.1 years
Owner-occupied homes
76%
Occupied homes
1,515

Source: U.S. Census Bureau, ACS 2022 5-year ZCTA estimates (income, age, and occupied housing tenure).

Bayfield County UCR book ZIP 54891 inherits

ZIP 54891 itself is about 49 people per Census sq mi across 68.5 sq mi (3,338 residents), a postal settlement fact independent of the county UCR proxy.

ZIP 54891's 3,338 residents are about 20.6% of the 2024 county reporting population (16,220), a large postal share of a county-wide rate.

Bayfield County's 2024 UCR book concentrates in larceny-theft (57% of 91 offenses; mix index 4,176). ZIP 54891 inherits that county mix, not a postal-native split.

Bayfield County 2024 vs 2022: property counts -35% vs 2022. Year-over-year moves are county agency submissions, still not ZIP-native.

Bayfield County offense mix (2024)

Mix index is HHI × 10,000 on county offense-type shares. Distinct from the per-100K rates in the hero; still county-agency data, not a ZIP-native FBI table.

Nationwide peers for ZIP 54891

Similar county violent rate (~62/100K)

Similar Census population (~3,338)

County detail: Bayfield County · State atlas: Wisconsin

Sources: U.S. Census Bureau (ZIP population, land area, 2020 ZCTA-to-county relationship file, ACS 5-year estimates) and FBI Uniform Crime Reporting (UCR) Program, Crime in the United States (CIUS) Table 10 (county-level crime, attributed via ZIP-to-county crosswalk).

Verify with Census.gov Geography and FBI.gov UCR.

Read our methodology , how this data is sourced, computed, and verified.

Every figure on PlainCrime is rendered directly from FBI Uniform Crime Reporting (UCR) source data, no number is typed in by an editor. This page combines Census ZIP-level figures with a ZIP-to-county crosswalk to attribute FBI UCR crime data honestly, no figure is typed in by an editor. See our editorial standards & corrections policy, the methodology behind these numbers, or report a data error.