Mackinac Island, MI has a C safety grade (53/100) with a violent crime rate of 168 per 100,000, 52% below the national average.

FBI UCR 2024 Per-capita rates FBI UCR + NIBRS

Mackinac Island, MI Crime Rate & Safety

Violent and property crime rates per 100,000 residents, drawn directly from FBI Uniform Crime Reporting data. Compare against state and national averages.

PlainCrime home → About this data
C
Safety grade
Average
168.1
Violent / 100K
8571.4
Property / 100K
1K
Population
-52%
vs U.S. avg

The verdict

Mackinac Island earns a C safety grade: violent crime runs 52% below the U.S. average, placing it close to the national middle for violent crime.

C
PlainCrime safety grade
-52%
violent crime vs. U.S. average
46th
percentile of 8,986 U.S. cities
8,571.4
property crimes per 100K

Crime data sourced from the FBI Uniform Crime Reporting program, covering violent crime, property crime, and individual offense categories. Safety grades reflect a composite analysis of violent and property crime rates benchmarked against national averages. For context on how crime statistics are collected and what they mean for community safety, read our guide to understanding FBI crime data.

Is Mackinac Island, MI safe? Mackinac Island has a violent crime rate of 168.1 per 100,000 residents in 2024, according to FBI Uniform Crime Report (UCR) data, 52% lower than the national average and 61% below the Michigan average. The city receives a safety grade of C (Average). Property crime rate: 8571.4/100K. Population: 595.

FBI UCR Data Snapshot: Mackinac Island, MI

Mackinac Island, MI, reporting population 595 in 2024, recorded 1 violent crimes and 51 property crimes in the FBI Uniform Crime Reporting (UCR) Program's Table 8 city-level submissions. The city's violent crime rate works out to 168.1 per 100,000 residents, while the property crime rate reaches 8571.4 per 100,000. Combining those two rates against national benchmarks yields a composite safety grade of C (Average), scoring 53 out of 100.

Within the violent crime count, aggravated assault accounted for 1 incidents, robbery 0, murder 0, and rape 0 in 2024. Property crime splits into larceny-theft (49), burglary (2), motor vehicle theft (0), and arson (0). Larceny-theft and other property offenses typically dominate city crime counts, and larceny-theft leads Mackinac Island's mix at 94.2% of all Part I offenses.

Against the national violent crime average, Mackinac Island runs 52% below the US benchmark, and 61% below the Michigan statewide rate. Translated to per-capita risk, the 2024 figures imply roughly a 1 in 11 statistical chance of being named in a crime report that year, narrowing to 1 in 595 for a violent offense. UCR figures reflect offenses reported to and submitted by local law enforcement and may undercount unreported crime.

These figures come from the FBI's Uniform Crime Reporting (UCR) program, which compiles offenses voluntarily submitted by local law enforcement agencies. Rates are expressed per 100,000 residents so a small town and a large city sit on the same scale, 50 burglaries mean something very different in a town of 2,000 than in a city of 500,000. Two caveats matter when reading any city's numbers. First, a year with missing or partial agency reporting can understate true crime, so a sudden drop sometimes reflects a reporting gap rather than a real safety gain. Second, UCR counts reported offenses, not convictions, and many crimes are never reported at all. Treat a grade as one input among several, not a final verdict on a place.

Is Mackinac Island, MI Safe? Safety Assessment

Based on 2024 FBI crime data, Mackinac Island, MI receives a safety grade of C (Average) with a composite safety score of 53/100. The city is significantly safer than the national average, with violent crime 52% below the US benchmark.

Your statistical chance of being a crime victim in Mackinac Island is approximately 1 in 11 , with a 1 in 595 chance of being a violent crime victim. The most common crime type is larceny-theft, accounting for 94% of all reported offenses.

Safety assessments are based on FBI UCR reported crime statistics. Actual safety varies by neighborhood, time of day, and individual circumstances. Crime reporting rates differ across jurisdictions.

Safety Overview

C 53/100
Average
Composite safety score
based on FBI UCR data
Violent Crime Rate
168.1/100K
violent crimes per 100K residents
-52% vs US
Property Crime Rate
8571.4/100K
property crimes per 100K residents
+401% vs US
Total Crimes
52
reported in 2024
Population
595
2024 Census-based estimate

Crime Rate Breakdown, How Each Offense Compares

Each offense category's rate per 100,000 residents, benchmarked against the national average. Bars show the rate relative to the highest-rate offense in this city.

Murder 0.0/100K
Rape 0.0/100K
Robbery 0.0/100K
Aggravated Assault 168.1/100K
Burglary 336.1/100K
Larceny-Theft 8235.3/100K
Motor Vehicle Theft 0.0/100K
Arson 0.0/100K

How this works: Each bar shows the offense rate per 100,000 residents relative to the most frequent offense in this city. ▲▼ indicators compare against the FBI UCR national rate for that offense category. A longer bar means a higher per-capita rate, it does not imply the city is dangerous; use it to understand the mix of crime types. Full methodology →

Crime Breakdown (2024)

Category Count Rate /100K
Violent Crime 1 168.1
Murder 0 0
Rape 0 0
Robbery 0 0
Aggravated Assault 1 168.1
Property Crime 51 8571.4
Burglary 2 336.1
Larceny-Theft 49 8235.3
Motor Vehicle Theft 0 0
Arson 0 0

Per-Capita Risk Assessment

Overall Crime Risk
1 in 11
Statistical chance of being a crime victim based on 2024 data
Violent Crime Risk
1 in 595
Statistical chance of being a violent crime victim

These are statistical averages based on reported crimes. Actual risk varies significantly by neighborhood, time of day, and individual circumstances.

Crime Type Distribution (2024)

Larceny-Theft 49 (94.2%)
Burglary 2 (3.8%)
Aggravated Assault 1 (1.9%)

Mackinac Island vs Michigan vs National Average

Mackinac Island
Violent168.1/100K
Property8571.4/100K
GradeC
Michigan
Violent431.4/100K
Property1395.3/100K
National Average
Violent352/100K
Property1711/100K

How Mackinac Island ranks nationally

Mackinac Island vs. every U.S. city

Violent crime per 100,000 residents, FBI UCR 2024. Lower is safer.

168 46th percentile lower than 46% of 8,986 U.S. cities

0–100: 3,427 U.S. cities (38%). Below this entry. 100–200: 2,003 U.S. cities (22%). This entry sits in this band. 200–300: 1,232 U.S. cities (14%). Above this entry. 300–400: 742 U.S. cities (8%). Above this entry. 400–500: 511 U.S. cities (6%). Above this entry. 500–600: 325 U.S. cities (4%). Above this entry. 600–700: 199 U.S. cities (2%). Above this entry. 700–800: 134 U.S. cities (1%). Above this entry. 800–900: 94 U.S. cities (1%). Above this entry. 900–1,000: 77 U.S. cities (1%). Above this entry. 1,000–1,100: 59 U.S. cities (1%). Above this entry. 1,100–1,200: 38 U.S. cities (0%). Above this entry. 1,200–1,300: 27 U.S. cities (0%). Above this entry. 1,300–1,400: 24 U.S. cities (0%). Above this entry. 1,400–1,500: 12 U.S. cities (0%). Above this entry. 1,500–1,600: 16 U.S. cities (0%). Above this entry. 1,600–1,700: 10 U.S. cities (0%). Above this entry. 1,700–1,800: 12 U.S. cities (0%). Above this entry. 1,800–1,900: 11 U.S. cities (0%). Above this entry. 1,900–2,000: 4 U.S. cities (0%). Above this entry. 2,000+: 29 U.S. cities (0%). Above this entry. This city 0 2,000+ every reporting city, bucketed by value

Each bar is a band of values; taller bars hold more U.S. cities. The dashed line + filled bar mark this entry. Hover or tap any bar for its full count, share, and where it sits relative to this entry.

Source FBI Uniform Crime Reporting (UCR) Program · 2024

Mackinac Island vs. nearby cities — violent vs. property crime. X axis violent crime per 100K, Y axis property crime per 100K, split by the national averages. 9 cities; the anchor city is ringed. Mackinac Island vs. nearby cities — violent vs. property crime SAFEST HIGHEST CRIME 151 1,924 Violent crime per 100K → 938 9,257 Property crime per 100K → Mackinac Island: 168 violent · 8,571 property per 100K · grade C Mackinac Island Detroit: 1,781 violent · 4,305 property per 100K · grade F Grand Rapids: 910 violent · 2,481 property per 100K · grade F Warren: 542 violent · 1,554 property per 100K · grade D Sterling Heights: 229 violent · 1,042 property per 100K · grade B Ann Arbor: 303 violent · 1,716 property per 100K · grade C Lansing: 1,345 violent · 2,499 property per 100K · grade F Dearborn: 293 violent · 2,000 property per 100K · grade C Clinton Township: 320 violent · 1,430 property per 100K · grade C Safety grade A / B C D / F
Source: FBI Uniform Crime Reporting (UCR) Program · split lines are the U.S. national averages

Nearby Cities in Michigan

Compare Mackinac Island against neighboring cities in the same state, or use our side-by-side compare tool to benchmark two cities directly.

Detroit
F
Pop: 651,171
Violent: 1781.3/100K
Property: 4305.3/100K
Grand Rapids
F
Pop: 195,913
Violent: 910.1/100K
Property: 2480.7/100K
Warren
D
Pop: 135,843
Violent: 541.8/100K
Property: 1554/100K
Sterling Heights
B
Pop: 133,058
Violent: 229.2/100K
Property: 1042.4/100K
Ann Arbor
C
Pop: 118,025
Violent: 302.5/100K
Property: 1715.7/100K

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the crime rate in Mackinac Island, MI? ▼
Mackinac Island has a violent crime rate of 168.1 per 100,000 residents and a property crime rate of 8571.4 per 100,000, based on 2024 FBI UCR data.
Is Mackinac Island, MI safe? ▼
Mackinac Island receives a safety grade of C (Average), with a safety score of 53/100. The violent crime rate is 52% below the national average and 61% below the Michigan average.
What is the population of Mackinac Island, MI? ▼
The reporting population for Mackinac Island is 595 as of 2024.
How many crimes were reported in Mackinac Island? ▼
In 2024, Mackinac Island reported 1 violent crimes and 51 property crimes, for a total of 52 reported offenses.
What are the odds of being a crime victim in Mackinac Island? ▼
Based on 2024 data, the statistical chance of being a crime victim in Mackinac Island is approximately 1 in 11, with a 1 in 595 chance of being a violent crime victim. These are statistical averages and actual risk varies by neighborhood and circumstance.
What is the most common crime in Mackinac Island? ▼
The most common crime type in Mackinac Island is larceny-theft, accounting for 94.2% of all reported crimes (49 incidents in 2024).

Understanding Crime Data

►
Understanding Crime Rates
How per-capita rates are calculated and what they mean
 ►
Violent vs Property Crime
Key differences between crime categories
 ►
FBI Crime Stats Explained
How the FBI collects and reports UCR data
 ►
Crime, Housing & Schools
How safety connects to housing costs and school quality

Data as of 2024. Source: FBI Uniform Crime Reporting (UCR) Program.

Crime rates are calculated per 100,000 population. Not all agencies report complete data. FBI Crime in the United States (CIUS) Table 8. Population figures referenced from U.S. Census Bureau estimates where noted; state-level comparisons cross-check against state UCR programs. Verify with FBI.gov UCR, Census.gov QuickFacts, and HUD.gov fair-market rents.

Disclaimer: This information is provided for informational purposes only and does not constitute professional advice. Data is sourced from the FBI Uniform Crime Reporting (UCR) Program. Consult a qualified professional before making decisions based on this data.

Read our methodology , how this data is sourced, computed, and verified.

All federal data sources used on this page
Federal data Last updated 2026 Free public data

Coverage

50 states + DC

Full national footprint

Update cadence

Quarterly

Refreshed within 30 days of upstream release

Source agency

Federal

Authoritative data, no third-party aggregation

Page reliability score 94.0%
Industry baseline

Composite score weighing source authority, update freshness, and methodological transparency. 1.0 = full federal-source coverage with documented methodology and recent update.