Safest Cities in New York

FBI UCR Safest-Cities Snapshot: New York

New York's 50 safest cities for 2024 rank from Shawangunk Town (violent crime rate 0/100K) at the top of the list to Tonawanda Town (violent crime rate 82/100K) at the bottom of this top-50 selection. Rankings are drawn directly from FBI Uniform Crime Reporting (UCR) Program submissions and include only cities with reporting populations of 10,000 or more residents, which keeps per-capita rate calculations statistically stable. The average violent crime rate across these 50 cities is 47.9 per 100,000 residents — well below the US national benchmark commonly cited in the 350–400 range.

At the top of the list, Shawangunk Town recorded 0 violent crimes and 5 property crimes against a reporting population of 13,376 in 2024. That works out to a property crime rate of 37.4 per 100,000 residents alongside the 0/100K violent rate — both well below typical US municipal benchmarks. The top five safest New York cities on this list are Shawangunk Town, Scarsdale Village, Harrison Town, Mamaroneck Town, Lewisboro Town, each submitting Part I offense counts to the FBI UCR Program for 2024.

Violent crime rate is used as the primary ranking metric because the four Part I violent offenses (murder, rape, robbery, aggravated assault) have higher reporting consistency than property offenses, which vary with local policing priorities and insurance-driven reporting. New York cities that missed this list either fell below the 10,000-population threshold, had incomplete 2024 UCR submissions, or were consolidated into county agency totals rather than reporting individually. For context on how the FBI collects and publishes these statistics, consult the UCR Program documentation; agency participation is voluntary and coverage can shift from year to year.