Idaho Crime Grades: A-F Safety Ratings for 55 Cities (2024)

Statewide grade B

55 cities graded A+ through F based on 2024 FBI crime data. State overall score: 70/100 (Above Average).

What is Idaho’s crime safety grade?

Idaho earned an overall safety grade of B (score: 70/100, Above Average) based on 2024 FBI Uniform Crime Reporting (UCR) Program data, with a statewide violent crime rate of 234.7 per 100,000 and property crime rate of 754.4 per 100,000. PlainCrime graded 55 Idaho cities with reportable crime data against national benchmarks, producing an A+ through F score for each jurisdiction. Grades weigh violent and property crime rates: cities more than 50% below the national average typically earn A or A+, while cities significantly above average receive D or F ratings.

Across the 55 graded Idaho cities, 7 earned A+, 20 earned A, 17 received B, 8 landed at C, 1 received D, and 2 fell to F in the 2024 scoring. The highest-rated city is Soda Springs with a A+ grade (score: 94/100, violent rate 31.4/100K). The lowest-rated city is Challis with a F grade (score: 22/100, violent rate 856.5/100K).

Roughly 49% of graded cities in Idaho achieved an A or A+ rating, while 5% received a D or F. Cities missing from this table either did not submit complete 2024 UCR data, fell below the minimum population threshold for reliable rate calculation, or report through consolidated agencies that aggregate into county or regional totals instead of individual city figures. Grade boundaries use the national violent and property crime rate averages for 2024 as the reference point, so grades are directly comparable between Idaho and other states on the site.

A safety grade condenses several FBI Uniform Crime Reporting (UCR) measures into a single letter, ranking each state's violent and property crime rates against the national distribution rather than a fixed cutoff. A high grade therefore means a state compares well to its peers in a given year, not that it is free of crime. Grades move as the underlying rates move and as agency reporting completeness shifts from year to year. Two states with the same letter can have very different profiles: one may carry a higher violent-crime rate offset by low property crime, the other the reverse. Use the grade as a quick orientation, then read the component rates beneath it to see what is actually driving the number for this state.

A+

7 cities

20 cities

17 cities

8 cities

1 cities

2 cities

Soda Springs

31.4
Montpelier

0
Ponderay

44.6
Kimberly

53.4
Sun Valley

56.7
Preston

63.7
Grangeville

80.7
Moscow

18.7

What this shows Soda Springs reports the lowest violent-crime rate in Idaho. At 31.4 per 100K, it runs well below the Idaho average of 234.7. These eight cities anchor the safe end of the state.

#	Grade	City	Score	Violent Rate	Property Rate	Population
1	A+	Soda Springs	94	31.4/100K	313.7/100K	3,188
2	A+	Montpelier	93	0/100K	765.9/100K	2,742
3	A+	Ponderay	92	44.6/100K	446/100K	2,242
4	A+	Kimberly	92	53.4/100K	356/100K	5,618
5	A+	Sun Valley	90	56.7/100K	453.5/100K	1,764
6	A+	Preston	90	63.7/100K	382/100K	6,282
7	A+	Grangeville	90	80.7/100K	268.9/100K	3,719
8	A	Moscow	89	18.7/100K	1015.6/100K	26,684
9	A	Buhl	89	83.9/100K	335.8/100K	4,765
10	A	Rexburg	88	69.7/100K	522.9/100K	40,164
11	A	Salmon	87	119.2/100K	178.7/100K	3,357
12	A	Weiser	87	129.2/100K	48.4/100K	6,194
13	A	Rathdrum	86	64.2/100K	850.2/100K	12,467
14	A	Priest River	86	108/100K	378/100K	1,852
15	A	Fruitland	85	97.8/100K	544.9/100K	7,157
16	A	Sandpoint	83	85.7/100K	1000.2/100K	10,498
17	A	Jerome	83	111.9/100K	694.1/100K	13,399
18	A	Ketchum	82	110.3/100K	854.5/100K	3,628
19	A	Middleton	82	129.9/100K	597.4/100K	11,550
20	A	Plummer	80	87.2/100K	1307.8/100K	1,147
21	A	Meridian	80	146.8/100K	571.4/100K	140,353
22	A	Post Falls	79	151.6/100K	642.7/100K	46,835
23	A	St. Anthony	79	169.2/100K	459.3/100K	4,137
24	A	Hailey	78	179.3/100K	478.1/100K	10,039
25	A	Hagerman	78	201.2/100K	201.2/100K	994
26	A	Bellevue	77	193.9/100K	465.3/100K	2,579
27	A	Mountain Home	75	200.9/100K	525.8/100K	16,927
28	B	Bonners Ferry	73	181.6/100K	980.4/100K	2,754
29	B	Wendell	73	230.3/100K	493.6/100K	3,039
30	B	Rigby	72	173.7/100K	1181.4/100K	5,756
31	B	Shelley	72	207.4/100K	886/100K	5,305
32	B	Osburn	71	237/100K	651.7/100K	1,688
33	B	American Falls	71	267.7/100K	288.2/100K	4,857
34	B	Spirit Lake	70	237.6/100K	712.9/100K	2,525
35	B	Lewiston	69	191.2/100K	1312.9/100K	35,036
36	B	Parma	69	276.8/100K	415.1/100K	2,168
37	B	St. Maries	69	278.8/100K	358.4/100K	2,511
38	B	Coeur d'Alene	68	241.5/100K	955.5/100K	57,561
39	B	Kellogg	68	280.6/100K	521/100K	2,495
40	B	Blackfoot	63	288/100K	909.4/100K	13,196
41	B	Payette	62	295.8/100K	989.8/100K	8,790
42	B	Emmett	62	342.2/100K	410.7/100K	8,766
43	B	Boise	61	293.8/100K	1110/100K	235,223
44	B	Heyburn	60	348.2/100K	616/100K	3,734
45	C	McCall	58	310.4/100K	1241.6/100K	4,188
46	C	Nampa	58	353.1/100K	742.3/100K	118,950
47	C	Idaho Falls	54	356.5/100K	1209.3/100K	68,716
48	C	Gooding	53	391.5/100K	965.8/100K	3,831
49	C	Pocatello	52	341.2/100K	1586.5/100K	58,618
50	C	Chubbuck	50	265.1/100K	2686.7/100K	16,600
51	C	Twin Falls	49	416.6/100K	1126.4/100K	55,932
52	C	Caldwell	46	452.8/100K	977.3/100K	71,115
53	D	Rupert	30	640.7/100K	750.1/100K	6,399
54	F	Garden City	22	656.1/100K	1435.6/100K	12,956
55	F	Challis	22	856.5/100K	963.6/100K	934

Frequently Asked Questions

What is Idaho's overall crime safety grade?

Idaho has an overall safety grade of B (score: 70/100). This is based on the state's aggregate violent crime rate of 234.7 per 100K and property crime rate of 754.4 per 100K compared to national averages.

How many cities in Idaho have an A+ safety grade?

7 cities in Idaho earned an A+ safety grade (2024), meaning their crime rates are well below the national average. 20 additional cities earned an A grade.

Which is the safest city in Idaho?

Soda Springs is the highest-rated city in Idaho with a A+ grade (score: 94/100). Its violent crime rate is 31.4 per 100K.

Nearby States, Crime Grades

Compare Idaho's grade distribution with neighboring states, or use the compare tool to benchmark jurisdictions side-by-side.

Explore More

Idaho Crime Overview → Safest Cities in Idaho → All State Grades →

Other States

AL AK AZ AR CA CO CT DE DC FL GA HI IL IN IA KS KY LA ME MD MA MI MN MS MO MT NE NV NH NJ NM NY NC ND OH OK OR PA RI SC SD TN TX UT VT VA WA WV WI WY

Source: FBI Uniform Crime Reporting (UCR) Program, 2024. Safety scores based on violent and property crime rates vs. national averages published in FBI Crime in the United States (CIUS) Table 8. Population figures reference U.S. Census Bureau estimates where FBI-reported populations are unavailable. Verify with FBI.gov UCR and Census.gov QuickFacts.

Read our methodology , how this data is sourced, computed, and verified.

Every figure on PlainCrime is rendered directly from FBI Uniform Crime Reporting (UCR) source data, no number is typed in by an editor. This page draws directly on FBI Uniform Crime Reporting source data, no figure is typed in by an editor. See our editorial standards & corrections policy, the methodology behind these numbers, or report a data error.