New York Crime Grades
F327 cities graded A+ through F based on 2024 FBI crime data. State overall score: 0/100 (High Risk).
FBI UCR Safety Grade Snapshot: New York
New York earned an overall safety grade of F (score: 0/100, High Risk) based on 2024 FBI Uniform Crime Reporting (UCR) Program data, with a statewide violent crime rate of 380 per 100,000 and property crime rate of 1661.2 per 100,000. PlainCrime graded 327 New York cities with reportable crime data against national benchmarks, producing an A+ through F score for each jurisdiction. Grades weigh violent and property crime rates: cities more than 50% below the national average typically earn A or A+, while cities significantly above average receive D or F ratings.
Across the 327 graded New York cities, 47 earned A+, 37 earned A, 45 received B, 53 landed at C, 24 received D, and 121 fell to F in the 2024 scoring. The highest-rated city is Afton Village with a A+ grade (score: 100/100, violent rate 0/100K). The lowest-rated city is Herkimer Village with a F grade (score: 0/100, violent rate 1191.5/100K).
Roughly 26% of graded cities in New York achieved an A or A+ rating, while 44% received a D or F. Cities missing from this table either did not submit complete 2024 UCR data, fell below the minimum population threshold for reliable rate calculation, or report through consolidated agencies that aggregate into county or regional totals instead of individual city figures. Grade boundaries use the national violent and property crime rate averages for 2024 as the reference point, so grades are directly comparable between New York and other states on the site.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is New York's overall crime safety grade?
How many cities in New York have an A+ safety grade?
Which is the safest city in New York?
Nearby States — Crime Grades
Compare New York's grade distribution with neighboring states, or use the compare tool to benchmark jurisdictions side-by-side.
Explore More
Other States
Source: FBI Uniform Crime Reporting (UCR) Program, 2024. Safety scores based on violent and property crime rates vs. national averages published in FBI Crime in the United States (CIUS) Table 8. Population figures reference U.S. Census Bureau estimates where FBI-reported populations are unavailable. Verify with FBI.gov UCR and Census.gov QuickFacts.
Read our methodology — how this data is sourced, computed, and verified.